The Discernment Team has spent several months discussing and reviewing documents and resources regarding the splintering of the United Methodist Church. Whenever possible, the Discernment Team prioritizes and reviews primary sources for information. In times of high anxiety and uncertainty, rumors, unverified information, speculation, and opinions often flood our inboxes, social media feeds, and conversations.
As a result, we encourage you to get information about a specific organization from that organization’s official publications, statements, and leaders. We also encourage you to review information from the United Methodist Church (www.umc.org), UM News (https://www.umnews.org), and the Global Methodist Church (www.globalmethodist.org). The information and resources provided on this page are supported by primary sources whenever possible.
Asbury’s Discernment Timeline
Updates from the Discernment Team
Click below to read emails sent to the congregation regarding our discernment process.
Listening Sessions – October, 2022
Listening sessions provide Asbury UMC members an opportunity to share from their hearts and from their own understanding so that the Discernment Team is able to share a concise report of this information with the Church Council. These sessions are not a time for voting or making plans for our future, but opportunities to allow the Holy Spirit to work through our conversations.
Listening sessions are provided for specific groups such as Adult Sunday School classes, leadership teams, and our youth who are professing members. Specific Listening Sessions will be held for the following Sunday School classes and groups: Adult Singles, Agape, Beloved, Challengers, Crossroads, FISH, Friendship, Good Samaritan, Journeymen, Ladies’ Bible Study, Light, Pathfinders, Seekers, Student Ministry/Youth, and YAMS. Leaders for each of these groups have been contacted with specific times and locations for these listening sessions.
General Listening Sessions are offered for those who aren’t in a Sunday School or Small Group or are unable to meet at the designated time. Attendance at all General Sessions is limited to 50 people to ensure everyone has an opportunity to be heard. We ask each person attend only one Listening Session.
Registration for Listening Sessions has closed and sessions have concluded.
The Discernment Team will process this information and create a church-wide survey which will be administered at the beginning of 2023. This survey will be used to gather additional information and comments from the members of Asbury UMC as another way to ensure every person has a chance to be heard.
Information Session – November, 2022
On Wednesday, November 16, 2022, Rev. Mike Holly provided a brief report on the Discernment Team’s work from the October Listening Sessions. He also provided a timeline and next steps for the team in their work for our church. This timeline is available on this webpage or by clicking here. Our hope is that this first report helped clarify few questions as well as provided you with further information to help you personally and prayerfully discern.
For those who were unable to attend the in-person session on November 16, Pastor Mike pre-recorded a video with the same information and content. This 16 minute video was sent to the entire congregation at the same time the in-person session was occurring.
The Discernment Team is making some final edits to the Church-Wide Survey after some initial drafts were looked over by research and data specialists in the private sector. The Discernment Team plans to launch the survey in early February.
If you are sharing an email address with someone in your household or you are not currently receiving email from Asbury, we ask that you update your contact information with us to ensure everyone receives the survey. We ask that you do this as soon as possible so there is no delay in receiving the survey link. If you have questions, contact the church office.
Our goal is to have as many people as possible participate in the survey so that we receive thoughts and views from across our membership. Our Discernment Team will send out reminders about the survey and its deadline. The Team plans on reporting the data from this survey as well as other data collected during the listening sessions, information sessions, and individual communications with the Discernment Team to the Church Council in late Spring or early Summer.
In order to prepare to take the survey, please review the information on this website, including the frequently asked questions and timeline of what to expect. We also encourage you to listen to a conversation with Pastors Mike Holly and Robert Mercer where they help unpack portions of the United Methodist Book of Discipline and explain how laws are written, interpreted, and enforced in the United Methodist Church. They also talk about scripture: how United Methodists read it, interpret it, and live by it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is Asbury going to leave The United Methodist Church?
A: That is ultimately up to the members of Asbury United Methodist Church. Your pastors and your Discernment Team are not able to make that decision. The listening sessions in October are the first step in the process of answering this question.
Q: What is the current United Methodist stance on homosexuality?
A: Bishop Holston is helpful in framing the stance on homosexuality in the Book of Discipline: “While affirming that all persons are people of sacred worth and that God’s Grace is available to all, the United Methodist Church (UMC) does not condone the practice of homosexuality and considers it not compatible with Christian teaching (¶161f). Furthermore, we are reminded that the leaders in our congregations be persons of Christian character, discipline, commitment, as well as loyal to the ethical standards of the UMC as set forth in our Social Principles (¶244.3). It is obvious that the discussion concerning homosexuality is one of our more divisive issues. It captivates our attention and dominates our conversations as well as making it difficult to focus on the mission and ministry of the church. As we seek to live together in Christian community, let us always remember that God calls us to be in a faithful ministry with all persons through the Gospel of Jesus Christ.” (source) Here are other paragraphs from the Book of Discipline:
¶ 4. Article IV. Inclusiveness of the Church
The United Methodist Church is a part of the church universal, which is one Body in Christ. The United Methodist Church acknowledges that all persons are of sacred worth. All persons without regard to race, color, national origin, status,4 or economic condition, shall be eligible to attend its worship services, participate in its programs, receive the sacraments, upon baptism be admitted as baptized members, and upon taking vows declaring the Christian faith, become professing members in any local church in the connection.5 In The United Methodist Church no conference or other organizational unit of the Church shall be structured so as to exclude any member or any constituent body of the Church because of race, color, national origin, status or economic condition.6
4. Amended 1992.
5. Amended 2000.
6. See Judicial Council Decisions 242, 246, 340, 351, 362, 377, 398, 594, 601, and Decisions 4 and 5, Interim Judicial Council.
¶ 214. Eligibility
The United Methodist Church is a part of the holy catholic (universal) church, as we confess in the Apostles’ Creed. In the church, Jesus Christ is proclaimed and professed as Lord and Savior. All people may attend its worship services, participate in its programs, receive the sacraments and become members in any local church in the connection (¶ 4). In the case of persons whose disabilities prevent them from reciting the vows, their legal guardian[s], themselves members in full covenant relationship with God and the Church, the community of faith, may recite the appropriate vows on their behalf.
¶ 304.3 Qualifications for Ordination
While persons set apart by the Church for ordained ministry are subject to all the frailties of the human condition and the pressures of society, they are required to maintain the highest standards of holy living in the world. The practice of homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching. Therefore self-avowed practicing homosexuals1 are not to be certified as candidates, ordained as ministers, or appointed to serve in The United Methodist Church.2
1. “Self-avowed practicing homosexual” is understood to mean that a person openly acknowledges to a bishop, district superintendent, district committee of ordained ministry, board of ordained ministry, or clergy session that the person is a practicing homosexual. See Judicial Council Decisions 702, 708, 722, 725, 764, 844, 984, 1020
2. See Judicial Council Decisions 984, 985, 1027, 1028
Q: Is Asbury going to have same-sex marriages?
A: To answer this question, it is important to understand two important facts. First, the United Methodist Church’s Book of Discipline does not allow pastors or local churches to perform same-sex weddings (source). Second, a pastor is not forced to perform a wedding that she or he does not wish to perform. We do not know what the future holds, but a recent gathering of large church pastors and General Conference delegates saw the vast majority pledging that churches will not be forced to perform a wedding that they are morally opposed to allowing.
Q: Will we have an LGBTQ pastor?
A: The United Methodist Church’s Book of Discipline does not currently allow ordained clergy who are in same-sex relationships or marriages (source). The Board of Ordained Ministry in the North Alabama Conference of the United Methodist Church has followed the Book of Discipline in its practices and thus, the likelihood that this will occur is very, very low.
Q: Is the UMC changing its position on the virgin birth and the resurrection?
A: Here is a helpful answer from the United Methodist official website: “No. All of these positions are bedrock in the doctrinal standards of The United Methodist Church, more specifically in the Articles of Religion and the Confession of Faith. These cannot be altered without a two-thirds vote of the General Conference followed by a three-fourths aggregate approval of all annual conferences of The United Methodist Church worldwide. There is no basis to conclude such majorities can be achieved to alter the Articles and Confession for any reason.”
Virgin Birth and Divinity of Jesus
Articles of Religion, Article II:
“The Son, who is the Word of the Father, the very and eternal God, of one substance with the Father, took man’s nature in the womb of the blessed Virgin.”
Confession of Faith
Article II:
“We believe in Jesus Christ, truly God and truly man, in whom the divine and human natures are perfectly and inseparably united. He is the eternal Word made flesh, the only begotten Son of the Father, born of the Virgin Mary by the power of the Holy Spirit.”
Resurrection of Jesus Christ
Articles of Religion, Article III:
Christ did truly rise again from the dead, and took again his body, with all things appertaining to the perfection of man’s nature, wherewith he ascended into heaven, and there sitteth until he return to judge all men at the last day.
Confession of Faith
Article II:
“Jesus Christ… was buried, rose from the dead and ascended into heaven to be with the Father, from whence he shall return.”
Salvation apart from faith in Jesus Christ
Articles of Religion, Article IX:
“We are accounted righteous before God only for the merit of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, by faith.”
Confession of Faith
Article IX:
“We believe we are never accounted righteous before God through our works or merit, but that penitent sinners are justified or accounted righteous before God only by faith in our Lord Jesus Christ.”
Q: What is the UMC position on the interpretation of scripture?
A: The United Methodist Church is clear that the Scriptures of the Church are the primary source and criterion for the Christian faith and doctrine. John Wesley held a high view of Scripture as seen in Articles V and VI in the Articles of Religion from the Book of Discipline. As stated above, the Articles of Religion “cannot be altered without a two-thirds vote of the General Conference followed by a three-fourths aggregate approval of all annual conferences of The United Methodist Church worldwide. There is no basis to conclude such majorities can be achieved to alter the Articles and Confession for any reason.” The membership vows of the United Methodist Church also include a clear statement about Scripture.
Q: When is the next General Conference and why has it been postponed?
A: The only body that can officially speak for our denomination is the General Conference. This is the body that makes any changes to the Book of Discipline (source). The General Conference is led by the Council of Bishops, but they do not have a vote. An equal number of pastors and lay persons from churches around the globe are elected from their Annual or Central Conferences. Annual Conferences or Central Conference with greater number of members have more representatives at General Conference.
The next General Conference will be held April 23 – May 3, 2024 in Charlotte, North Carolina (source). Delegates were already selected back in 2019 for the postponed General Conference of 2020. General Conference was postponed initially because of the COVID-19 global pandemic and again because of the lack of vaccinations for global delegates as well as the very long wait time for visas.
Q: Why are some churches leaving now? And why are “traditionalist” churches the ones mostly leaving?
A: At the 2019 Special Called General Conference, the delegates added a new paragraph to the Book of Discipline. This paragraph (¶ 2553) allows for churches to leave the United Methodist denomination through a process known as disaffiliation. The process of disaffiliation includes a church wide vote by the Church Conference as well as several financial expenses. The disaffiliation is not final until the Annual Conference votes to approve the church’s decision. This paragraph (¶ 2553) is set to expire in December 2023. Some churches seem to be ready to leave now because they already know where their church stands or because they are anxious that waiting will cause them to lose members. The North Alabama Conference of the United Methodist Church provides a three-month discernment process including consultation from the Annual Conference (source). Churches with a vast majority of “traditionalist” members are the ones in the discernment process to disaffiliate. Churches with a majority of “traditionalist” members but also a fair number of more “progressive” members are either choosing to wait for General Conference 2024 for more clarity or they are voting to disaffiliate and causing financial and spiritual strain to their church family – creating winners and losers in a church wide vote. There will be ample time to remain United Methodist as well as to disaffiliate if that is the will of the church family.
Q: What happened at the Special Called Annual Conference for North Alabama in December of 2022?
A: The Special Called Annual Conference for North Alabama United Methodist Churches was held at the BJCC in downtown Birmingham on December 10, 2022. There were 198 churches in the North Alabama Conference that had used the process of disaffiliation made possible by ¶ 2553 in the United Methodist Book of Discipline and had reached a 2/3 majority approval in their local congregation to approve disaffiliating from the United Methodist denomination (source). The annual conference, in the last step of the process of disaffiliation, overwhelmingly supported the votes of the local churches. 198 United Methodist Congregations left the denomination as did many of their pastors. 440 churches currently remain. According to AL.com, “75 of the 198 disaffiliating churches have membership under 50, and 134 have membership under 100. The average in-person weekly worship attendance at the disaffiliating churches was 66, while 150 of them reported in-person weekly attendance less than 50.
Q: What is the Global Methodist Church? What is the WCA (Wesley Covenant Association)?
A: The Wesley Covenant Association (WCA) was established in 2016, but the roots of this group stretch out to various groups and churches for many years. The churches and pastors of the Wesley Covenant Association are “traditionalist” and have a passion for every church in their fellowship to make disciples of Jesus Christ as well as to hold firm in their stance on human sexuality. They are generally opposed to any church or pastor breaking the rules of the Book of Discipline. After the Special Called General Conference of 2019, the WCA began planning a new denomination for United Methodist Churches and pastors who no longer wanted to be in a “big tent” denomination. When General Conference was postponed due to the COVID-19 global pandemic, the lack of vaccinations, and the long wait time for visas in both 2021 and 2022, the WCA decided to launch this new denomination in May of 2022 (source). This new denomination was named the Global Methodist Church. Early disaffiliations of United Methodist Churches included members of these organizations. However, large “traditionalist” churches who were members of the WCA in Montgomery, Alabama, and Madison, Alabama, decided not to join the Global Methodist Church. Instead, they joined the Free Methodist Church or began a new connection of churches that may become a denomination at some point. In September of 2022, the very “traditionalist” United Methodist bishops of Africa have announced that they will not align with the WCA or the new Global Methodist Church (source).
Q: If I do not agree with an official UMC stance on any issue; why should I stay? Why should I leave?
A: “Progressive” members of many United Methodists have stayed within the denomination even though they have disagreed with the official UMC stance. Many have stated that they have stayed out of love for the local church itself – to continue to support the ministry and mission of the church they love. Others have stayed because of the relationships in a small group or Sunday school class. Others, of course, have stayed hoping that the stance would one day change. It is reasonable to assume that many of those same “progressive” members will continue to be committed to the ministries and mission of their local United Methodist Church as well as to the denomination itself if there are no changes at General Conference 2024. If there are changes, then it is reasonable to assume that some “traditionalist” members will choose to stay while some may choose to ask their local church to disaffiliate, or they will find a new congregation that better fits their theological stance. It has been helpful for many to consider whether they are “compatible” in their theological stances.
That leads us to believe that there are, as many have outlined, four possible places for people to find themselves. This is an imperfect, yet helpful framework:
| Traditional Non-Compatibilist | Traditional Compatibilist | Progressive Compatibilist | Progressive Non-Compatibilist |
| These are church members whose understanding of Scripture is in line with the current wording of the Book of Discipline which forbids same-sex marriage and the ordination of people who are practicing homosexuals. Their concerns are of such importance to them that they would rather be in a church where all agree on these matters than be in a church where they would feel personally compromised by a denomination with a diverse view on human sexuality. | These are church members who hold traditional views on human sexuality much like the first category, but they believe that they can still be compatible with others within the United Methodist Connection. For instance, a pastor might not want to be forced into performing a same-sex marriage but can live in a denomination where other pastors are allowed to perform such ceremonies. A traditional compatibilist holds to their own traditional understanding but also values the unity, mission, and impact of the United Methodist Church in so many areas beyond the scope of human sexuality. | Some progressive compatibilist Christians may have started out as Traditional Compatibilists, but their views have changed in recent years. They would often like to see the denomination ordain anyone who qualifies as a pastor and they would also welcome the marriage of same-sex persons who are committed Christian couples. They, too, hold on to their own progressive understanding but also value the bond, mission, and impact of the United Methodist Church | Church members in this final group look at the issues of human sexuality through an understanding of Scripture calling for justice and care for the marginalized. They strive for full inclusion of all regardless of sexual orientation including same-sex marriages and ordination. This is of such high concern for them that they only want to be in a denomination that reflects these beliefs. |
Q: Is every church in the process of discernment with the Annual Conference deciding to disaffiliate?
A: No, some churches are choosing to remain in the United Methodist Church. Some are deciding to remain indefinitely while others are waiting for the results of General Conference 2024.
Q: What will happen to our pastors and staff if our church decides to remain in the United Methodist Church? If we decide to disaffiliate?
A: Unlike a local church where a 2/3 majority of the Church Conference must approve a motion to disaffiliate, each pastor already has the option to join a new denomination as an ordained pastor. Any pastor could leave at any time. It is possible that a pastor will not choose the same denomination as the local church she or he currently serves. That pastor would then hopefully be assigned to a new church or another appointment within the denomination. The local church would then work with their denominational leaders or representatives to receive the pastoral team needed for their unique context. It is not known how lay staff members will react to any changes in the denomination. It is also not clear what the financial strength of any church will be after making any significant change and what that might mean for staff retention.
Q: What about global United Methodists (such as United Methodists in Ukraine, Russia, Africa, and Southeast Asia)? Will they disaffiliate?
A: As mentioned above, there are bishops and churches in Africa that will remain United Methodist and will not join the Global Methodist Church (source). We are not aware of similar statements or announcements from eastern Europe and Southeast Asia.
Q: What is Asbury’s role in leadership in the North Alabama Conference of the United Methodist Church?
A: Asbury United Methodist Church, Birmingham, is a leader in the North Alabama Conference of the United Methodist Church. Our members and our pastors have a voice in what lies ahead in North Alabama. Our Annual Conference has turned numerous times to our wonderful worship staff to aid in worship leadership at Conference gatherings. Our Annual Conference has also turned to Asbury UMC asking that we host virtual meetings and gatherings as well as a Service of Ordination for new clergy.
Meet the Discernment Team
In November, 2021 the Church Council of Asbury United Methodist Church approved the creation of a twelve-person Discernment Team to help guide the congregation through a time of exploration and information gathering to determine who we are as a church body and who we hope to be in relation to the United Methodist Church. The Discernment Team is made up of representatives from the four committees required by the Book of Discipline (Church Council, Trustees, Finance, and Staff-Parish Relations) as well as our clergy, and four at-large members. While committee membership composition will change in 2023, the members of the Discernment Team will remain consistent to finish the work begun in 2022.
Meet the Discernment Team
HENRY AVERYT
At-Large Member
BROOKS BURDETTE
Trustees Committee Representative
DANIEL CRAWFORD
At-Large Member
REV. MAGGIE DUNAWAY
Pastor of Congregational Care
REV. MIKE HOLLY
Senior Pastor
REV. ROBERT MERCER
Associate Pastor
CHRISTY MILLER
At-Large Member
JAY NICHOLS
Finance Committee Representative
MIKE NORTHRUP
Church Council Representative
JESSICA NORTON
At-Large Member
JANET O’NEIL
Lay Leader
NATAN SHAR
Staff-Parish Relations Committee Representative
Ex-Officio Support
ROBYN WHITE
Facilitator/Spiritual Direction
DAVID MILLER
Administrative Support
Additional Resources
The following resources have been compiled to provide additional information from primary sources for you to review as you continue to research and discern.
The United Methodist Book of Discipline
The Book of Discipline contains the doctrine and polity of the United Methodist Church.
North Alabama Conference “Discerning Our Future” Website
Our Conference has put together Frequently Asked Questions, resources for discerning churches and clergy, and other information as it relates to discernment, disaffiliation, and the United Methodist Church moving forward.
Report of Disaffiliating Churches from North Alabama Conference
A list of churches who disaffiliated from the North Alabama Conference during the December 2022 Special Called Annual Conference.
Ask the UMC Addresses Misinformation and Rumors around Disaffiliation
Ask The UMC offers a series of questions and answers to help clear up some common misperceptions or misinformation around disaffiliation.
Wespath General Conference Website
Wespath is the organization that hosts clergy and staff pensions in the United Methodist Church. This page shares legislation updates for General Conference 2024.
Wespath Disaffiliation Webpage
This page shares podcasts and information regarding how a church can work with Wespath through a process of disaffiliation and specifically how it impacts the local church’s commitment to pension funding for its pastors.